Ytukyg

I am using Angular 5 with Reactive forms and need to make use of the valueChanges in order to disable required validation dynamically

component class:

export class UserEditor implements OnInit {



    public userForm: FormGroup;

    userName: FormControl;

    firstName: FormControl;

    lastName: FormControl;

    email: FormControl;

    loginTypeId: FormControl;

    password: FormControl;

    confirmPassword: FormControl;

...



ngOnInit() {

    this.createFormControls();

    this.createForm();

    this.userForm.get('loginTypeId').valueChanges.subscribe(



            (loginTypeId: string) => {

                console.log("log this!");

                if (loginTypeId === "1") {

                    console.log("disable validators");

                    Validators.pattern('^[0-9]{5}(?:-[0-9]{4})?$')]);

                    this.userForm.get('password').setValidators();

                    this.userForm.get('confirmPassword').setValidators();



                } else if (loginTypeId === '2') {

                    console.log("enable validators");

                    this.userForm.get('password').setValidators([Validators.required, Validators.minLength(8)]);

                    this.userForm.get('confirmPassword').setValidators([Validators.required, Validators.minLength(8)]);



                }



                this.userForm.get('loginTypeId').updateValueAndValidity();



            }



        )

}

createFormControls() {

    this.userName = new FormControl('', [

        Validators.required,

        Validators.minLength(4)

    ]);

    this.firstName = new FormControl('', Validators.required);

    this.lastName = new FormControl('', Validators.required);

    this.email = new FormControl('', [

      Validators.required,

      Validators.pattern("[^ @]*@[^ @]*")

    ]);

    this.password = new FormControl('', [

       Validators.required,

       Validators.minLength(8)

    ]);

    this.confirmPassword = new FormControl('', [

        Validators.required,

        Validators.minLength(8)

    ]);



}



createForm() {

 this.userForm = new FormGroup({

      userName: this.userName,

      name: new FormGroup({

        firstName: this.firstName,

        lastName: this.lastName,

      }),

      email: this.email,

      loginTypeId: this.loginTypeId,

      password: this.password,

      confirmPassword: this.confirmPassword

    });

}

However when I run it I get a browser javascript error

UserEditor.html:82 ERROR RangeError: Maximum call stack size exceeded

    at SafeSubscriber.tryCatcher (tryCatch.js:9)

    at SafeSubscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscription.js.Subscription.unsubscribe (Subscription.js:68)

    at SafeSubscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscriber.js.Subscriber.unsubscribe (Subscriber.js:124)

    at SafeSubscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscriber.js.SafeSubscriber.__tryOrUnsub (Subscriber.js:242)

    at SafeSubscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscriber.js.SafeSubscriber.next (Subscriber.js:186)

    at Subscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscriber.js.Subscriber._next (Subscriber.js:127)

    at Subscriber.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subscriber.js.Subscriber.next (Subscriber.js:91)

    at EventEmitter.webpackJsonp.../../../../rxjs/_esm5/Subject.js.Subject.next (Subject.js:56)

    at EventEmitter.webpackJsonp.../../../core/esm5/core.js.EventEmitter.emit (core.js:4319)

    at FormControl.webpackJsonp.../../../forms/esm5/forms.js.AbstractControl.updateValueAndValidity (forms.js:3377)

"log this!" is loggedcalled repeatedly like it is called recursively which is why their is a stack error

If I remove the valueChanges.subscribe the code work apart from removing the validation conditionally.

Why is it calling valueChanges.subscribe recursively?

The problem is that you modify the value of the field inside of the valueChanges event handler for that same field, causing the event to be triggered again:

this.userForm.get('loginTypeId').valueChanges.subscribe(

  (loginTypeId: string) => {

    ...

    this.userForm.get('loginTypeId').updateValueAndValidity(); <-- Triggers valueChanges!

}

Try adding distinctUntilChanged() in the pipeline just before subscribe(). It should filter out those "change" events where value was not actually changed.

Well actually, the true answer is, if you want to subscribe to any form changes and still run patchValue inside it, then you should just add the {emitEvent: false} option to patchValue, thus the patching will not trigger another change detection

code:

this.formGroup

    .valueChanges

    .subscribe( _ => {

        this.formGroup.get( 'controlName' ).patchValue( _val, {emitEvent: false} );

    } );

PS. This is also less tedious than subscribing to each form control one-by-one to avoid triggering change max call stack exceeded. Especially if you form has 100 controls to subscribe to.

Now to elaborate further, if you still need to updateValueAndValidity inside the subscription, then I suggest you use the distinctUntilChanged rxjs operator, to only run the subscription, when some value changes.

Now we will also have to make it a custom validation function, because by default, distinctUntilChanged validates objects by pointer and the pointer is new on every change.

this.formGroup

    .valueChanges

    .distinctUntilChanged((a, b) => JSON.stringify(a) === JSON.stringify(b))

    .subscribe( _ => {

        this.formGroup.get( 'controlName' ).patchValue( _val, {emitEvent: false} );

        this.formGroup.get( 'controlName' ).updateValueAndValidity();

    } );

And voila, we are patching and updating, without running into the maximum call stack!

My answer is just development of this one.

By adding distinctUntilChanged() in the pipeline just before subscribe() you avoid the "Maximum call stack size exceeded" because

distinctUntilChanged method only emit when the current value is different than the last.

The usage:

this.userForm.get('password')

  .valueChanges.pipe(distinctUntilChanged())         

  .subscribe(val => {})

Documentation