Port Forwarding always fail despite correct settings - Connection Refused [closed]
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
hi trying to make my web server public but am failing. I've went to many sites and read many port forwarding guides but still am unable to discern what is wrong.
port tests have failed no matter how much i tried. (had an attempted where i placed lots of port combinations in the port forwarding page but to no avail..
some additional information:
am running on raspberry pi 3 B+, raspbian. No firewall or anything.
I've tried turning off my firewall on my router completely, thinking it might be the router's firewall issue but to no avail.
public ip gotten from whatismyip (changed) : 101.251.120.22
WAN ip (shown on ASUS router page): 172.23.118.172
Raspberry pi local ip: 192.168.1.244
Port my server is on: 8123
Links:
Asus Router Port Forwarding img: https://imgur.com/Mkgrr4Y
WAN general settings: https://imgur.com/6F92HXS
netstat results: https://imgur.com/3qUT3xJ
Raspberry Pi ip: https://imgur.com/TJ74Pra
any help.. thanks!
networking raspberry-pi port portforwarding
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
closed as off-topic by Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze Nov 20 at 7:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about general computing hardware and software are off-topic for Stack Overflow unless they directly involve tools used primarily for programming. You may be able to get help on Super User." – Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
hi trying to make my web server public but am failing. I've went to many sites and read many port forwarding guides but still am unable to discern what is wrong.
port tests have failed no matter how much i tried. (had an attempted where i placed lots of port combinations in the port forwarding page but to no avail..
some additional information:
am running on raspberry pi 3 B+, raspbian. No firewall or anything.
I've tried turning off my firewall on my router completely, thinking it might be the router's firewall issue but to no avail.
public ip gotten from whatismyip (changed) : 101.251.120.22
WAN ip (shown on ASUS router page): 172.23.118.172
Raspberry pi local ip: 192.168.1.244
Port my server is on: 8123
Links:
Asus Router Port Forwarding img: https://imgur.com/Mkgrr4Y
WAN general settings: https://imgur.com/6F92HXS
netstat results: https://imgur.com/3qUT3xJ
Raspberry Pi ip: https://imgur.com/TJ74Pra
any help.. thanks!
networking raspberry-pi port portforwarding
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
closed as off-topic by Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze Nov 20 at 7:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about general computing hardware and software are off-topic for Stack Overflow unless they directly involve tools used primarily for programming. You may be able to get help on Super User." – Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
1
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
hi trying to make my web server public but am failing. I've went to many sites and read many port forwarding guides but still am unable to discern what is wrong.
port tests have failed no matter how much i tried. (had an attempted where i placed lots of port combinations in the port forwarding page but to no avail..
some additional information:
am running on raspberry pi 3 B+, raspbian. No firewall or anything.
I've tried turning off my firewall on my router completely, thinking it might be the router's firewall issue but to no avail.
public ip gotten from whatismyip (changed) : 101.251.120.22
WAN ip (shown on ASUS router page): 172.23.118.172
Raspberry pi local ip: 192.168.1.244
Port my server is on: 8123
Links:
Asus Router Port Forwarding img: https://imgur.com/Mkgrr4Y
WAN general settings: https://imgur.com/6F92HXS
netstat results: https://imgur.com/3qUT3xJ
Raspberry Pi ip: https://imgur.com/TJ74Pra
any help.. thanks!
networking raspberry-pi port portforwarding
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
hi trying to make my web server public but am failing. I've went to many sites and read many port forwarding guides but still am unable to discern what is wrong.
port tests have failed no matter how much i tried. (had an attempted where i placed lots of port combinations in the port forwarding page but to no avail..
some additional information:
am running on raspberry pi 3 B+, raspbian. No firewall or anything.
I've tried turning off my firewall on my router completely, thinking it might be the router's firewall issue but to no avail.
public ip gotten from whatismyip (changed) : 101.251.120.22
WAN ip (shown on ASUS router page): 172.23.118.172
Raspberry pi local ip: 192.168.1.244
Port my server is on: 8123
Links:
Asus Router Port Forwarding img: https://imgur.com/Mkgrr4Y
WAN general settings: https://imgur.com/6F92HXS
netstat results: https://imgur.com/3qUT3xJ
Raspberry Pi ip: https://imgur.com/TJ74Pra
any help.. thanks!
networking raspberry-pi port portforwarding
networking raspberry-pi port portforwarding
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
asked Nov 19 at 16:02
Eric Lim
36
36
closed as off-topic by Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze Nov 20 at 7:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about general computing hardware and software are off-topic for Stack Overflow unless they directly involve tools used primarily for programming. You may be able to get help on Super User." – Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
closed as off-topic by Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze Nov 20 at 7:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about general computing hardware and software are off-topic for Stack Overflow unless they directly involve tools used primarily for programming. You may be able to get help on Super User." – Ron Maupin, stevieb, Pang, Mark, Werner Henze
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
1
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53
add a comment |
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
1
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
1
1
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53
add a comment |
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Your ISP is using CGN, so you cannot forward the port on the ISP NAPT router, which would be necessary. Your residential service contract prohibits running servers to the public Internet, so the ISP doesn't really care that it doesn't work for you.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:14
@RonMaupin does this mean that i have no chance of forwarding my server to public? if so, then how can i ever make homeassistant available remotely?
– Eric Lim
Nov 19 at 16:50
1
That is correct. You would need a business account, or move to IPv6 and use global addressing. Your ISP will not forward a particular port to you, and having a publicly accessible server is a violation of your residential terms of service, anyway. In any case, this is a question to ask on Super User, not here.
– Ron Maupin
Nov 19 at 16:53