If $tan(A-B)=1$ and $sec(A+B)=2/sqrt{3}$, find the minimum positive value of $B$
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
If $tan(A-B)=1$ and $sec(A+B)=2/sqrt{3}$, find the minimum positive value of $B$
I am using $tan(A-B)=1$, so $A-B=npi+pi/4$ and $A+B = 2npipmpi/6$. Solving these I am getting $B =7pi/24$ and $A =37pi/24$.
The book I am refering to has marked the answer as $19pi/24$.
Am I doing something wrong?
trigonometry
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
If $tan(A-B)=1$ and $sec(A+B)=2/sqrt{3}$, find the minimum positive value of $B$
I am using $tan(A-B)=1$, so $A-B=npi+pi/4$ and $A+B = 2npipmpi/6$. Solving these I am getting $B =7pi/24$ and $A =37pi/24$.
The book I am refering to has marked the answer as $19pi/24$.
Am I doing something wrong?
trigonometry
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
If $tan(A-B)=1$ and $sec(A+B)=2/sqrt{3}$, find the minimum positive value of $B$
I am using $tan(A-B)=1$, so $A-B=npi+pi/4$ and $A+B = 2npipmpi/6$. Solving these I am getting $B =7pi/24$ and $A =37pi/24$.
The book I am refering to has marked the answer as $19pi/24$.
Am I doing something wrong?
trigonometry
If $tan(A-B)=1$ and $sec(A+B)=2/sqrt{3}$, find the minimum positive value of $B$
I am using $tan(A-B)=1$, so $A-B=npi+pi/4$ and $A+B = 2npipmpi/6$. Solving these I am getting $B =7pi/24$ and $A =37pi/24$.
The book I am refering to has marked the answer as $19pi/24$.
Am I doing something wrong?
trigonometry
trigonometry
edited Nov 2 at 15:15
user10354138
6,570623
6,570623
asked Nov 2 at 14:32
user62956
112
112
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54
add a comment |
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
You correctly have
$$
A=B+frac{pi}{4}+npi
$$
Therefore $A+B=2B+pi/4+npi$. Hence
$$
cosleft(2B+frac{pi}{4}+npiright)=frac{sqrt{3}}{2}=cosfrac{pi}{6}
$$
Therefore either
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
or
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=-frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
In the first case
$$
2B=-frac{pi}{12}+(2m-n)pi
$$
which is minimal positive for $2m-n=1$, giving
$$
B=frac{11}{24}pi
$$
In the second case,
$$
2B=-frac{5}{12}pi+(2m-n)pi
$$
that gives the minimal positive solution
$$
B=frac{7}{24}pi
$$
You are right and the book is wrong.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
First of all, your values for $A$ and $B$ satisfy the given formulae and $B$ is positive, so their proposed minimum for $B$ is definitely wrong.
One thing you did miss in your reasoning is that there are two families of solutions to $secleft(thetaright) = frac{2}{sqrt{3}}$; there should be a $pm$ with $frac{pi}{6}$ in your formula for $A+B$. However, it turns out that you get the minimum value for $B$ from the family of solutions you gave, and the minimum positive value of $B$ is indeed $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Explicitly, $$A-B = frac{pi}{4} + npi,$$ $$A+B = pm frac{pi}{6} + 2mpi,$$ so $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(pmfrac{1}{6} - frac{1}{4} + left(2m - nright)right),$$ and then we see that $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(-frac{1}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z}$$ or $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(frac{-5}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z},$$ and the smallest positive value of $B$ is then $frac{7pi}{24}$.
EDIT: I see that you have/somebody has now edited your question to include the $pm$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Your answer is correct. For all $n in mathbb{Z}$:
$$tan(A-B) = 1 implies A-B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n$$
Recall that secant, like cosine, is an even function. (Which you've apparently referred to as well, after the format editing.)
$$sec(-theta) = sec(theta)$$
$$sec(A+B) = frac{2}{sqrt 3} implies cos(A+B) = frac{sqrt 3}{2} implies pm(A+B) = frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
Therefore, there are $2$ cases, neither of which yields the book's answer.
Case $1$: With $+(A+B)$, by subtracting the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-frac{pi}{6}-2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{12}-pi n$$
$$B = frac{pi n}{2}-frac{pi}{12}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{11pi}{24}$.
Case $2$: With $-(A+B)$, by adding the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{5pi}{12}+3pi n$$
$$B = -frac{3pi n}{2}-frac{5pi}{24}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{7pi}{24}$.
Thus, the minimum positive value of $B$, as you correctly found, is $frac{7pi}{24}$.
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
You correctly have
$$
A=B+frac{pi}{4}+npi
$$
Therefore $A+B=2B+pi/4+npi$. Hence
$$
cosleft(2B+frac{pi}{4}+npiright)=frac{sqrt{3}}{2}=cosfrac{pi}{6}
$$
Therefore either
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
or
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=-frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
In the first case
$$
2B=-frac{pi}{12}+(2m-n)pi
$$
which is minimal positive for $2m-n=1$, giving
$$
B=frac{11}{24}pi
$$
In the second case,
$$
2B=-frac{5}{12}pi+(2m-n)pi
$$
that gives the minimal positive solution
$$
B=frac{7}{24}pi
$$
You are right and the book is wrong.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
You correctly have
$$
A=B+frac{pi}{4}+npi
$$
Therefore $A+B=2B+pi/4+npi$. Hence
$$
cosleft(2B+frac{pi}{4}+npiright)=frac{sqrt{3}}{2}=cosfrac{pi}{6}
$$
Therefore either
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
or
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=-frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
In the first case
$$
2B=-frac{pi}{12}+(2m-n)pi
$$
which is minimal positive for $2m-n=1$, giving
$$
B=frac{11}{24}pi
$$
In the second case,
$$
2B=-frac{5}{12}pi+(2m-n)pi
$$
that gives the minimal positive solution
$$
B=frac{7}{24}pi
$$
You are right and the book is wrong.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
You correctly have
$$
A=B+frac{pi}{4}+npi
$$
Therefore $A+B=2B+pi/4+npi$. Hence
$$
cosleft(2B+frac{pi}{4}+npiright)=frac{sqrt{3}}{2}=cosfrac{pi}{6}
$$
Therefore either
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
or
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=-frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
In the first case
$$
2B=-frac{pi}{12}+(2m-n)pi
$$
which is minimal positive for $2m-n=1$, giving
$$
B=frac{11}{24}pi
$$
In the second case,
$$
2B=-frac{5}{12}pi+(2m-n)pi
$$
that gives the minimal positive solution
$$
B=frac{7}{24}pi
$$
You are right and the book is wrong.
You correctly have
$$
A=B+frac{pi}{4}+npi
$$
Therefore $A+B=2B+pi/4+npi$. Hence
$$
cosleft(2B+frac{pi}{4}+npiright)=frac{sqrt{3}}{2}=cosfrac{pi}{6}
$$
Therefore either
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
or
$$
2B+frac{pi}{4}+npi=-frac{pi}{6}+2mpi
$$
In the first case
$$
2B=-frac{pi}{12}+(2m-n)pi
$$
which is minimal positive for $2m-n=1$, giving
$$
B=frac{11}{24}pi
$$
In the second case,
$$
2B=-frac{5}{12}pi+(2m-n)pi
$$
that gives the minimal positive solution
$$
B=frac{7}{24}pi
$$
You are right and the book is wrong.
answered Nov 2 at 15:03
egreg
175k1383198
175k1383198
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
First of all, your values for $A$ and $B$ satisfy the given formulae and $B$ is positive, so their proposed minimum for $B$ is definitely wrong.
One thing you did miss in your reasoning is that there are two families of solutions to $secleft(thetaright) = frac{2}{sqrt{3}}$; there should be a $pm$ with $frac{pi}{6}$ in your formula for $A+B$. However, it turns out that you get the minimum value for $B$ from the family of solutions you gave, and the minimum positive value of $B$ is indeed $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Explicitly, $$A-B = frac{pi}{4} + npi,$$ $$A+B = pm frac{pi}{6} + 2mpi,$$ so $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(pmfrac{1}{6} - frac{1}{4} + left(2m - nright)right),$$ and then we see that $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(-frac{1}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z}$$ or $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(frac{-5}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z},$$ and the smallest positive value of $B$ is then $frac{7pi}{24}$.
EDIT: I see that you have/somebody has now edited your question to include the $pm$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
First of all, your values for $A$ and $B$ satisfy the given formulae and $B$ is positive, so their proposed minimum for $B$ is definitely wrong.
One thing you did miss in your reasoning is that there are two families of solutions to $secleft(thetaright) = frac{2}{sqrt{3}}$; there should be a $pm$ with $frac{pi}{6}$ in your formula for $A+B$. However, it turns out that you get the minimum value for $B$ from the family of solutions you gave, and the minimum positive value of $B$ is indeed $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Explicitly, $$A-B = frac{pi}{4} + npi,$$ $$A+B = pm frac{pi}{6} + 2mpi,$$ so $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(pmfrac{1}{6} - frac{1}{4} + left(2m - nright)right),$$ and then we see that $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(-frac{1}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z}$$ or $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(frac{-5}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z},$$ and the smallest positive value of $B$ is then $frac{7pi}{24}$.
EDIT: I see that you have/somebody has now edited your question to include the $pm$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
First of all, your values for $A$ and $B$ satisfy the given formulae and $B$ is positive, so their proposed minimum for $B$ is definitely wrong.
One thing you did miss in your reasoning is that there are two families of solutions to $secleft(thetaright) = frac{2}{sqrt{3}}$; there should be a $pm$ with $frac{pi}{6}$ in your formula for $A+B$. However, it turns out that you get the minimum value for $B$ from the family of solutions you gave, and the minimum positive value of $B$ is indeed $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Explicitly, $$A-B = frac{pi}{4} + npi,$$ $$A+B = pm frac{pi}{6} + 2mpi,$$ so $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(pmfrac{1}{6} - frac{1}{4} + left(2m - nright)right),$$ and then we see that $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(-frac{1}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z}$$ or $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(frac{-5}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z},$$ and the smallest positive value of $B$ is then $frac{7pi}{24}$.
EDIT: I see that you have/somebody has now edited your question to include the $pm$.
First of all, your values for $A$ and $B$ satisfy the given formulae and $B$ is positive, so their proposed minimum for $B$ is definitely wrong.
One thing you did miss in your reasoning is that there are two families of solutions to $secleft(thetaright) = frac{2}{sqrt{3}}$; there should be a $pm$ with $frac{pi}{6}$ in your formula for $A+B$. However, it turns out that you get the minimum value for $B$ from the family of solutions you gave, and the minimum positive value of $B$ is indeed $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Explicitly, $$A-B = frac{pi}{4} + npi,$$ $$A+B = pm frac{pi}{6} + 2mpi,$$ so $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(pmfrac{1}{6} - frac{1}{4} + left(2m - nright)right),$$ and then we see that $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(-frac{1}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z}$$ or $$B = frac{pi}{2}left(frac{-5}{12} + kright), quad k in mathbb{Z},$$ and the smallest positive value of $B$ is then $frac{7pi}{24}$.
EDIT: I see that you have/somebody has now edited your question to include the $pm$.
edited Nov 2 at 15:27
answered Nov 2 at 15:01
Sam Streeter
1,479417
1,479417
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Your answer is correct. For all $n in mathbb{Z}$:
$$tan(A-B) = 1 implies A-B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n$$
Recall that secant, like cosine, is an even function. (Which you've apparently referred to as well, after the format editing.)
$$sec(-theta) = sec(theta)$$
$$sec(A+B) = frac{2}{sqrt 3} implies cos(A+B) = frac{sqrt 3}{2} implies pm(A+B) = frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
Therefore, there are $2$ cases, neither of which yields the book's answer.
Case $1$: With $+(A+B)$, by subtracting the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-frac{pi}{6}-2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{12}-pi n$$
$$B = frac{pi n}{2}-frac{pi}{12}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{11pi}{24}$.
Case $2$: With $-(A+B)$, by adding the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{5pi}{12}+3pi n$$
$$B = -frac{3pi n}{2}-frac{5pi}{24}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{7pi}{24}$.
Thus, the minimum positive value of $B$, as you correctly found, is $frac{7pi}{24}$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Your answer is correct. For all $n in mathbb{Z}$:
$$tan(A-B) = 1 implies A-B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n$$
Recall that secant, like cosine, is an even function. (Which you've apparently referred to as well, after the format editing.)
$$sec(-theta) = sec(theta)$$
$$sec(A+B) = frac{2}{sqrt 3} implies cos(A+B) = frac{sqrt 3}{2} implies pm(A+B) = frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
Therefore, there are $2$ cases, neither of which yields the book's answer.
Case $1$: With $+(A+B)$, by subtracting the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-frac{pi}{6}-2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{12}-pi n$$
$$B = frac{pi n}{2}-frac{pi}{12}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{11pi}{24}$.
Case $2$: With $-(A+B)$, by adding the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{5pi}{12}+3pi n$$
$$B = -frac{3pi n}{2}-frac{5pi}{24}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{7pi}{24}$.
Thus, the minimum positive value of $B$, as you correctly found, is $frac{7pi}{24}$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Your answer is correct. For all $n in mathbb{Z}$:
$$tan(A-B) = 1 implies A-B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n$$
Recall that secant, like cosine, is an even function. (Which you've apparently referred to as well, after the format editing.)
$$sec(-theta) = sec(theta)$$
$$sec(A+B) = frac{2}{sqrt 3} implies cos(A+B) = frac{sqrt 3}{2} implies pm(A+B) = frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
Therefore, there are $2$ cases, neither of which yields the book's answer.
Case $1$: With $+(A+B)$, by subtracting the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-frac{pi}{6}-2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{12}-pi n$$
$$B = frac{pi n}{2}-frac{pi}{12}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{11pi}{24}$.
Case $2$: With $-(A+B)$, by adding the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{5pi}{12}+3pi n$$
$$B = -frac{3pi n}{2}-frac{5pi}{24}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{7pi}{24}$.
Thus, the minimum positive value of $B$, as you correctly found, is $frac{7pi}{24}$.
Your answer is correct. For all $n in mathbb{Z}$:
$$tan(A-B) = 1 implies A-B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n$$
Recall that secant, like cosine, is an even function. (Which you've apparently referred to as well, after the format editing.)
$$sec(-theta) = sec(theta)$$
$$sec(A+B) = frac{2}{sqrt 3} implies cos(A+B) = frac{sqrt 3}{2} implies pm(A+B) = frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
Therefore, there are $2$ cases, neither of which yields the book's answer.
Case $1$: With $+(A+B)$, by subtracting the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n-frac{pi}{6}-2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{12}-pi n$$
$$B = frac{pi n}{2}-frac{pi}{12}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{11pi}{24}$.
Case $2$: With $-(A+B)$, by adding the two equations to eliminate $A$, the following equation is obtained.
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+bigg(frac{pi}{6}+2pi nbigg)$$
$$-2B = frac{pi}{4}+pi n+frac{pi}{6}+2pi n$$
$$-2B = frac{5pi}{12}+3pi n$$
$$B = -frac{3pi n}{2}-frac{5pi}{24}$$
The minimum here is $B = frac{7pi}{24}$.
Thus, the minimum positive value of $B$, as you correctly found, is $frac{7pi}{24}$.
edited Nov 23 at 9:14
answered Nov 2 at 15:19
KM101
3,288417
3,288417
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2981818%2fif-tana-b-1-and-secab-2-sqrt3-find-the-minimum-positive-value-of%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
math.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/5020/…
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:36
$sec(theta)$ is an even function, so $sec(theta) = sec(-theta)$.
– KM101
Nov 2 at 14:53
Well it looks like your answer works, and your value of $B$ is smaller than theirs, so I'd say you're right.
– Sam Streeter
Nov 2 at 14:54